@wirecutter If @cirie_fields could bring one thing to the @survivorcbs island, what would it be? Spoiler: Not a freeze-dried meal, even after we had her try 12 of them. 😂 Tap the link in bio to watch Fields taste test a whole bunch of gnarly — and, in some cases, actually sort of tasty — emergency meal kits.
Survivor star Cirie Fields participates in a rapid-fire 'Would You Rather' game where she chooses her preferred survival item from a series of pairs. The winning item from each round advances in a tournament-style bracket, starting with a fishing rod and progressing through choices like a tarp, water filter, and electric lighter, with Cirie providing humorous justifications for each decision. The game culminates in a choice between an electric lighter and an emergency meal, where she emphatically rejects the meal based on a previous taste test.
What Would Cirie Fields Rather Have on 'Survivor'?
Verbal hook · 35%
Would you rather have a fishing rod or deodorant?
Visual hook · 10%
A medium shot of celebrity Cirie Fields looking directly at the camera, paired with a large, bold title text overlay.
[06]
Hook template
Steal this for your own video
What Would [recognizable figure] Choose: [option A] or [option B]?
— What Would a Navy SEAL Choose: a knife or a fire starter?
— What Would Gordon Ramsay Choose: a cast iron or an air fryer?
— What Would a Wall Street Trader Choose: index funds or crypto?
[07]
Hook and payoff
The promise the opener makes, and how the video pays it back
Hook
A direct, title-card question that frames the entire video's premise, introducing the subject and the high-stakes context of their choices.
Payoff
A pattern-breaking twist that uses an external reference or comedic cutaway to deliver the final verdict, often serving as a call-to-action or promotion for related content.
[08]
Narrative framework
The structural pattern this video runs on
Framework
The King of the Hill Gauntlet
A 'This or That' elimination tournament where the winner of each round becomes the new champion, facing a new challenger in the next round. The process continues until a final, ultimate winner is determined, with each choice revealing the subject's personality and priorities.
1
The Opening Gambit
The first choice is presented, establishing the initial 'champion' and the subject's core decision-making criteria (e.g., practicality over comfort).
2
The Champion's Reign
A series of rapid-fire challenges where the established champion defends its title against various challengers, reinforcing its value and revealing more about the subject's priorities with each justification.
3
The Dethroning
A pivotal moment where a new challenger defeats the reigning champion, resetting the stakes and creating a new narrative focus. This beat can repeat multiple times to escalate the drama.
4
The Final Showdown
The ultimate champion faces its final, most thematically relevant or unexpected challenger, leading to the video's climax.
Themes
survival
prioritization
humor
Techniques
rapid-fire questions
tournament bracket
Trends
would you rather game
Post caption
If @cirie_fields could bring one thing to the @survivorcbs island, what would it be? Spoiler: Not a freeze-dried meal, even after we had her try 12 of them. 😂 Tap the link in bio to watch Fields taste test a whole bunch of gnarly — and, in some cases, actually sort of tasty — emergency meal kits.
Text overlays
title · beginning
What Would Cirie Fields Rather Have on 'Survivor'?
contextual · beginning
Fishing rod
contextual · beginning
Deodorant
contextual · beginning
✓ Fishing rod
contextual · middle
Tarp
contextual · middle
✓ Tarp
contextual · middle
Water filter
contextual · middle
✓ Water filter
contextual · end
Electric lighter
contextual · end
✓ Electric lighter
call-to-action · end
Will Cirie's taste buds survive an emergency meal taste test? Find out on YouTube.
Transcript
Would you rather have a fishing rod or deodorant? Definitely a fishing rod. Who cares how I smell? A fishing rod or earplugs? Oh, lord. Sometimes I would prefer the earplugs, but I have to say the fishing rod because I can always feed myself. Myself. A fishing rod or a sleeping eye rank? A fishing rod. I like to be able to wake up quick if you don't no something crawling on you. If I have a mask on, I'm yeah. No. Fishing rod over an eye mask. A fishing rod or a tarp? Oh. I'm always good, and I hate to be wet. I might have to take the tarp over the fishing rod. A tarp or a flashlight? Who cares about the dark? I wanna stay dry. I'm taking a tarp over a flashlight. A tarp or a water filter? I think I have to take the water filter because I'm always thirsty. A water filter or walkie talkies? Water filter. I don't wanna talk to anybody anyway. Water filter or a rice cooker? Water filter. I know how to cook rice. As Emily. Water filter or electric lighter? Damn. I'll take the electric lighter because I can boil water with that. An electric lighter or a hammer? Do I look like I want a hammer? I'll take the electric lighter. Electric lighter or emergency meal? Better I tasted some of the meals, give me electrolytes.