@theholyblack
TikTok · Yap
@theholyblack Replying to @ilovecherrypies Old Spice today is not the same scent our grandfathers wore. The real version from the 1930s was warm spicy and straight out of a classic barbershop. That old formula disappeared when the company changed hands so me and my brother tried to bring it back to life. If you want that nostalgic barbershop smell again the one that takes you right back in time the aftershave that started our whole company is in the link.
Performance
Video #20491 · Yap
[01]
The creator responds to a viewer's comment by breaking down the exact scent profile of the original 1930s Shulton's Old Spice, detailing its top, heart, and base notes to explain why it differs from the modern version and to highlight its classic barbershop appeal.
[02]
[03]
4MFounder tells vintage fragrance origin@theholyblack · Origin Story
113.2K4×Perfumer explains problems with fragrances@teddy.haugen · Reaction
93.8K2.9×Creator recommends top four perfumes.@axvanillax · Buying List
4M8.9×Personal story about a perfume@paigelorenze · Show and Tell
1.4M16.1×Funny skit then fragrance recommendations@_devontewest · Skit
309.4KOld Spice ad with a lumberjack who needs a skin vacation@bradley.thor · Product Promo
239.3K65.4×Honest talking head product review@kendallalfred · Review
2M1.1×Man reviews weird WD-40 cologne@mschf · Novel Review
315.9K14×Fragrance expert debunks marketing lies@teddy.haugen · Hot Take
77.6K2.1×Creator asks audience for opinion@teddy.haugen · Anecdotal Philosophy
381.8KProduct vibe shown through montage@bradley.thor · Brand Showcase
1.7M2737.6×Comparing perfumes to laundry scents@moziwash · Rapid Fire Listicle[04]
[05]
What stops the scroll in the first 3 seconds
Title hook
Reply to ilovecherrypies's comment Wait... so that old ceramic bottle of Old Spice that my dad has on the top shelf of his closet from HIS grandfather isnt the same stuff that is made today?
Verbal hook
So the amount of people that have been reaching out to us, in regards to the difference between the OG, Scholten's Old Spice, and Procter and Gamble, the Good Spice you can get today.
Visual hook
Close-up shot of a man with a large beard and a green beanie sitting in a car, featuring a prominent user comment overlay in the top left corner that establishes the video's premise.
[07]
The promise the opener makes, and how the video pays it back
Hook
Validating the topic by citing overwhelming audience interest or a specific comment, immediately establishing the core comparison between a classic original and a modern iteration.
Payoff
Delivering a definitive, nostalgic verdict on the original item's unmatched quality, cementing its legendary status and teeing up a potential modern solution or alternative.
[08]
The structural pattern this video runs on
Framework
The Nostalgic Deep-Dive Deconstruction
Leveraging audience curiosity about a legacy product to deliver an authoritative, highly detailed breakdown of its original components, establishing expertise and building desire for the 'lost' quality.
The High-Level Thesis
Providing a broad, evocative summary of the original item's defining characteristics to set the baseline expectation and tone.
The Layered Deconstruction
Systematically breaking down the item's composition into distinct, technical tiers to demonstrate deep subject matter expertise and overwhelm the viewer with authoritative detail.
The Sensory Synthesis
Translating the dense technical breakdown back into a holistic, relatable description of the physical or sensory experience to ground the information.
Replying to @ilovecherrypies Old Spice today is not the same scent our grandfathers wore. The real version from the 1930s was warm spicy and straight out of a classic barbershop. That old formula disappeared when the company changed hands so me and my brother tried to bring it back to life. If you want that nostalgic barbershop smell again the one that takes you right back in time the aftershave that started our whole company is in the link.
contextual · beginning
Reply to ilovecherrypies's comment Wait... so that old ceramic bottle of Old Spice that my dad has on the top shelf of his closet from HIS grandfather isnt the same stuff that is made today?
So the amount of people that have been reaching out to us, in regards to the difference between the OG, Scholten's Old Spice, and Procter and Gamble, the Good Spice you can get today. The original Old Spice from Scholten's was a barbershop style, rich, warm, deep, almost like incense note like profile. The corn notes from the Scholten's was, like lemon and orange, nutmeg, aldehydes, and, like, the heart notes were, like, carnation, geranium, and cinnamon, and clove. And then the base notes were, like, vanilla, benzoin, musk, cedarwood, tonka bean, ambergris, just style warmth. And it bad, like, this heavy spice forward profile. It was, like, rich with essential real essential oils. It was, like, thick resinous, warm base. It just had that old school powdery barbershop classic splash on fragrance. You just can't beat it and you can't mistake it. It smelled more like