Viral Hooks
Trending short videosComparing bad and good design
C

@createwithalena

Instagram · Greenscreen Talking Head

@createwithalena bad design existed way before ai (trust me, i made plenty of it). but designing with ai without understanding what makes something good just makes a ton of bad stuff fast. here are three things wrongs 1. It should have one job. it’s a safety rule, a competition, a pizza party and a t-shirt giveaway all at once so the actual point (wear ur gloves) gets lost. 2. There should be one loud color. there are six text colors and 3 titles that do the same job are each a different color 3. Have one big thing first. ur eye bounces around because nothing there’s no path to follow one big thing gives it a place to start if people can’t understand the message the design failed! poster found on r/marketing not sure where it’s originally from. [graphic design, design tips, ai slop, bad design, ai design, poster design, visual hierarchy, design principles, design critique]

View original on Instagram

The edit1 shot · 12 text
Shots Text0:34

Performance

Views
621.5K
Likes
35.3K
Comments
181
Engagement
5.7%
Outlier
17.3×
Length · 14 Oct 2026
0:34

Video #46037 · Greenscreen Talking Head

Comparing bad and good designfrom @createwithalena

[01]

Overview

A graphic designer critiques a poorly designed safety poster, identifying three key flaws: a lack of a single clear message, inconsistent use of color, and poor visual hierarchy. She then presents a redesigned version of the poster that effectively applies these principles, using the comparison to teach fundamental design rules.

[02]

Simple outline

  1. 1Present a flawed example
  2. 2Show the superior alternative
  3. 3Diagnose flaws with a numbered list
  4. 4Deliver a final, actionable rule

[03]

Related videos

3.9M6.7×Before and after design fixes@createwithalena · Rapid Fire Listicle477.4KProblem, then quick design fix@createwithalena · Rapid Fire Listicle808.8K2.9×Rapid fire graphic design fixes@createwithalena · Rapid Fire Listicle939.9K13.3×Before and after design tips@createwithalena · Before/After Transformation60.8KSales page design critique and fix@pixeldesignlab · Good vs Bad54K1.1×Explaining a website design transformation@pixeldesignlab · Before/After Transformation5.3M17.8×Before and after design fixes@createwithalena · Good vs Bad130.1K1.7×Website redesign before and after@pixeldesignlab · Good vs Bad274.1K1.1×Fixing common website design mistakes@pixeldesignlab · Before/After Transformation1.2M14.7×Argument that simple defined shapes make for better design@hansloreidesign · Breakdown1.3M18.4×Rapid fire graphic design tips@fakeplasticbrands · Rapid Fire Listicle108.1K2.5×Designer's creative process for posters.@envato · Process

[04]

Classification

Format
Greenscreen Talking Head
Concepts
Good vs BadCase Study BreakdownBreakdown
Elements
Annotation OverlayDigital Composite OverlayTitle Text HookGreen Screen CompositeImage OverlayVoiceoverText Overlay
Account
Personal Brand
Topics
Graphic DesignDesignEducation

[05]

Hook analysis

What stops the scroll in the first 3 seconds

Title hook · 35%

AI SLOP REVIEW

Verbal hook · 50%

This is bad design and this is the same poster fixed.

Visual hook · 15%

A creator holds a microphone in front of a visually cluttered poster that has a large red 'X' graphic overlaid on it, immediately signaling a critique.

[06]

Hook template

Steal this for your own video

This is bad [thing being critiqued] and this is the same [thing being critiqued] fixed.

  • — This is bad web design and this is the same landing page fixed.
  • — This is a bad resume and this is the same resume fixed.
  • — This is bad meal prep and this is the same meal prep fixed.

[07]

Hook and payoff

The promise the opener makes, and how the video pays it back

Hook

A direct comparative judgment ('This is bad, this is the fix') that immediately establishes a problem/solution dynamic and the creator's authority.

Payoff

A concise, memorable, and universally applicable 'Golden Rule' is delivered, providing the ultimate takeaway and empowering the viewer with new, actionable knowledge.

[08]

Narrative framework

The structural pattern this video runs on

Framework

The Diagnostic Teardown

Critiquing a flawed example against a superior one by breaking down the failure into a short, numbered list of actionable principles, culminating in a universal rule.

  1. 1

    The Overwhelm Simulation

    The creator poses a series of rapid-fire rhetorical questions about the flawed example to make the viewer personally experience its core problem (e.g., confusion, inefficiency).

  2. 2

    Diagnostic #1: The First Principle Violation

    The first flaw is identified and explained as a violation of a clear, simply-named principle. Visual aids (text overlays, circles) are used to highlight the specific error on the 'bad' example.

  3. 3

    Diagnostic #2: The Second Principle Violation

    The second flaw is identified and explained, following the same pattern of naming a principle and visually demonstrating its violation.

  4. 4

    Diagnostic #3: The Third Principle Violation

    The third and final flaw is identified, often using a more dynamic visual demonstration (like a simulated eye-tracking path) to make an abstract concept tangible.

  5. 5

    The Synthesis & Broader Context

    The numbered principles are explicitly summarized as the reasons for the initial judgment, then connected to a larger, relevant topic (like AI) to give the lesson broader significance.

Themes

  • design education
  • visual communication
  • critique

Techniques

  • comparative analysis
  • principle-based explanation

Trends

  • design critique
  • educational content

Post caption

bad design existed way before ai (trust me, i made plenty of it). but designing with ai without understanding what makes something good just makes a ton of bad stuff fast. here are three things wrongs 1. It should have one job. it’s a safety rule, a competition, a pizza party and a t-shirt giveaway all at once so the actual point (wear ur gloves) gets lost. 2. There should be one loud color. there are six text colors and 3 titles that do the same job are each a different color 3. Have one big thing first. ur eye bounces around because nothing there’s no path to follow one big thing gives it a place to start if people can’t understand the message the design failed! poster found on r/marketing not sure where it’s originally from. [graphic design, design tips, ai slop, bad design, ai design, poster design, visual hierarchy, design principles, design critique]

Text overlays

  • title · beginning

    AI SLOP REVIEW

  • title · beginning

    same poster. 3 fixes.

  • title · beginning

    1/3 . one job

  • informational · middle

    safety rule

  • informational · middle

    competition

  • informational · middle

    pizza party

  • informational · middle

    t-shirt giveaway

  • informational · middle

    the fix: one message

  • title · middle

    2/3 . one loud color

  • title · middle

    3/3 . one big thing first

  • informational · end

    one job one loud color one big thing first

  • call-to-action · end

    save this for ur next poster

Transcript

This is bad design and this is the same poster fixed. What is this even for? A safety tier? A competition? Pizza party? Free t shirt giveaway? The main message of wear your gloves is repeated several tier, but it's still hard to understand. Everything's yelling, there's six text colors, and these three titles do the same job best are in different colors. Watch where your eye goes on this. It bounces around because there isn't a clear path to follow. So this is bad design because it's missing these three things. Even if a person made this by hand, it would still be bad design. Bad design existed before AI. If people can't tell what matters in a second, the design failed.

Comparing bad and good design | Viral Hooks